Dan, you amoral theist -- I mean moral atheist --
I think you understand that the reason to be "good" is not because of positive or negative feedback from some metaphysical punishment engine, but because it helps create the kind of world in which we prefer to live. Your moral righteousness echos between the spheres of time.
I predict that you will be reincarnated somewhere between the two extremes you mentioned - probably as an intestinal parasite in an eagle. You'll have a seat near the sphincter, where the view is best.
It is an honor to know you (not in the bibical sense).